What mining owners should test before a final investment decision, from engineering maturity and contingency to permits, financing and execution readiness.
The final investment decision, or FID, is the point at which an owner's board commits the capital to build a mining project. Before FID, the project is a set of studies, options and estimates. After it, contracts are awarded, equipment is ordered, and money starts to flow at a rate that is hard to reverse.
That makes FID the most important control point in a project's life. A sound decision rests on a project that is defined well enough to be built at the cost and schedule the board approves. A rushed one usually shows up later as a cost overrun or a delayed start of production. These are the factors owners should test before they commit.
1. Engineering Maturity
FID normally follows a feasibility study, and the estimate behind it is only as reliable as the engineering beneath it. Owners should know how complete the design really is: process flowsheets, layouts, major equipment specifications and quantities for the main disciplines. Under AACE International's estimate classification, a feasibility-level estimate is typically a Class 3 estimate. If the engineering is less mature than the estimate class claims, the accuracy range is wider than the board has been told.
2. A Credible Estimate and Contingency
The capital estimate should be built from quantities, current pricing and productivity assumptions that fit the site, not from factors carried over from another project. The questions worth asking are simple:
- Have the estimate's assumptions been tested against the actual costs of comparable delivered projects?
- Is contingency based on a quantitative risk analysis of this project, or on a flat percentage?
- What confidence level does the approved budget represent, for example P50 or P80, and does the board understand the difference?
- Are escalation, currency exposure and owner's costs carried separately and clearly?
3. A Realistic, Integrated Schedule
The schedule should integrate engineering, procurement, construction and commissioning, with a critical path the team can explain. Long-lead equipment, seasonal access such as winter roads or sealift, and the time needed to mobilize labour and camp are common sources of delay. A resource-loaded schedule also produces the manpower curve that tests whether the plan fits the camp, the logistics and the local labour market.
4. Permits, Agreements and Social Licence
A project cannot be built on schedule without the permits it needs to start construction, or a realistic plan to obtain the rest. In Canada, agreements with Indigenous communities and the commitments that come with them are central to whether a project can proceed. Owners should be clear about which approvals are already in hand, which are on the critical path, and what conditions are attached.
5. Financing and Lender Requirements
Most major mining projects are funded with a mix of equity, debt and other sources such as streaming or offtake agreements. Lenders usually appoint an independent engineer to review the feasibility study, estimate, schedule and execution plan before they commit. Their review will find the same weaknesses a board should be looking for, so it pays to find them first.
6. Execution Readiness
A good study does not deliver a project. People do. Before FID, owners should confirm:
- The delivery model and contracting strategy are decided. EPC, EPCM and owner-led models each place risk and control in different hands.
- Key contracts and long-lead purchase orders are ready to be awarded, with terms that have been negotiated, not just drafted.
- The owner's team is in place, with the people and project controls systems to manage cost, schedule, change, and contractor performance from day one.
- Infrastructure such as power, access roads, water and camp is defined and costed, not left as an allowance.
7. Market and Economic Assumptions
Commodity price, exchange rate and inflation assumptions drive the project's economics. Owners should see how sensitive the project's value is to each one, and how much a capital cost increase or a delay to first production would change the result. A project that only works at an optimistic price or a best-case schedule is carrying more risk than its headline returns suggest.
8. An Independent Review
An independent, cold-eyes review before FID tests the study from outside the team that produced it. It is most useful when the reviewers have built projects, not just designed them, and when it happens early enough that the findings can still change the plan.
Why It Matters
As we have written before, mining cost overruns are rarely bad luck. They usually trace back to decisions made before construction started: an estimate built on immature engineering, a schedule that ignored the site, or an owner's team put together too late. That is why early owner engagement matters so much. FID is the last point at which those problems are cheap to fix.
How Praetorian Helps
Praetorian's pre-construction and feasibility support helps owners reach FID with confidence. We review feasibility studies, test estimate assumptions against actual costs from projects we have delivered, challenge schedule and constructability assumptions for the site where the project will be built, and develop execution and contracting strategies. Our team works at arm's length from the engineering firms, so our advice stays independent, and we have supported owners in presenting their plans to financing bodies, including the World Bank.
Contact our team to talk about preparing your project for a final investment decision.